Sanitation
Policy Paper: Clean Streets, Thriving Communities
Prepared by the Sanitation Committee
Laura Rothrock and Tim Laughlin, Co-Chairs
NYC BID Association | December 2025Executive Summary
Sanitation is a core service provided by BIDs, encompassing sidewalk sweeping, servicing public garbage cans, and staging trash bags for DSNY pickup. In July 2024, BIDs faced a significant operational challenge when a new DSNY policy was introduced, threatening fines for leaving trash bags on sidewalks while servicing public bins, effective August 10, 2024. Through coordinated advocacy by the BID Association, enforcement was successfully delayed until January 2026, providing the 78 BIDs citywide the necessary time to plan and implement trash containerization strategies. Moving forward, the BID Association is committed to working with the new Administration to monitor this implementation, support less-resourced BIDs, and ensure compliance with the new Rule.
The Implementation of Commercial Trash Containerization
The Problem:
In 2024, BIDs were informed of a new DSNY policy that would fine them for leaving trash bags on sidewalks during the process of emptying public corner bins. The initial, short timeline for compliance posed significant siting, logistical, and resource barriers for BIDs. While the extension of enforcement until January 2026 was a victory, the challenge remains for all BIDs—especially the smaller ones—to fully transition to the new containerization mandate.
The Solution:
Monitor Implementation: Continue to work closely with DSNY, DOT, and the Deputy Mayor for Operations on monthly calls to ensure a smooth transition and monitor for any emerging concerns in 2026.
Support Compliance: Use the City Council allocation of $4 million to enable BIDs to purchase containers for trash staging and DSNY collection.
Acknowledge Good Faith Efforts: DSNY has confirmed that BIDs that have completed a walkthrough, have approved container sites, submitted applications, and are awaiting containers will be considered compliant with the new Rule.
Assist Smaller BIDs: Continue to work with newly established and smaller, less-resourced BIDs to help them navigate the complexities of this new Rule.
Conclusion
The successful advocacy to delay enforcement of the new DSNY Rule demonstrates the power of partnership between the City and BIDs. Moving forward, continued coordination and financial support are essential to ensure that BIDs, as core service providers, can comply with new mandates like containerization and maintain a clean, safe public realm.